Treating Luck as Policy Variable

Updated: 2026.01.12 17D ago 1 sources
Public policy should stop treating luck as mere anecdote and instead explicitly model and compensate for birth‑lottery effects (place of birth, parental status, early life exposures) when designing social insurance, immigration, and redistribution programs. That means building interventions that assume large stochastic differences in baseline opportunity rather than assuming meritocratic equality of starting conditions. — Reframing luck as an explicit policy input would change debates over welfare, migration, and education from moralizing arguments about effort to technical designs that mitigate accidental inequality.

Sources

Prove Me Wrong: Luck Determines Almost Everything
Jesse Singal 2026.01.12 100% relevant
Singal’s Cuba visit anecdote (90 miles separating vastly different life outcomes; street vs airport exchange rates) exemplifies how proximate geography and chance (who you’re born near) produce huge, concrete differences that policy must reckon with.
← Back to All Ideas