As 'gender' has expanded from male/female to an open‑ended identity menu, longitudinal findings about 'stability' in early‑transitioned children can mask shifts into ill‑specified 'gender‑diverse' buckets rather than clear reidentification or resolution. Without stable, pre‑registered operational definitions, headline rates (e.g., 81.6% stable identity) risk misinforming clinicians, courts, and legislators.
— If core constructs are unstable, evidence used to justify pediatric gender protocols and laws becomes unreliable, pressing for measurement standards before policy.
Jesse Singal
2025.09.23
100% relevant
The TransYouth Project monograph (Olson/deMayo) reports 81.6% identity stability over ~8 years, while the article argues this is ambiguous given definition creep and category changes like 'gender diverse.'
← Back to All Ideas