Rising entitlement obligations make a broad consumption tax (VAT or equivalent) politically and fiscally plausible in the United States, and existing measures—tariffs and state sales taxes—are serving as practical experiments. The argument reframes tariffs and trade policy as not just protectionist tools but as potential national revenue mechanisms that would spread tax burdens more widely across income levels.
— If true, a shift from income‑based to consumption‑based revenue would reshape progressivity debates, redistribution politics, and the social contract around Social Security and Medicare.
Mitch Daniels
2026.03.31
100% relevant
Mitch Daniels' February 2026 Washington Post essay (republished here) explicitly cites OECD VAT norms, estimates VAT shares (9–10% of middle‑class income in Europe), and reports about $289 billion in U.S. tariff collections as a 'dry run' for consumption taxation.
← Back to All Ideas