Value‑Diversity as Expertise Standard

Updated: 2026.01.04 24D ago 1 sources
When expert communities are judged by the public, technical competence matters but so does the spread of underlying values; a technical consensus drawn from a politically homogeneous expert class will be less legible and less trusted. Institutions should therefore assess expert panels and advisory bodies for ideological and demographic diversity as a legitimacy metric, not only for 'balance' but to improve public buy‑in. — Treating diversity of values among experts as a governance standard would change appointment rules, advisory‑panel design, and science communication strategies with broad effects on policymaking and trust.

Sources

The crisis of expertise is about values
2026.01.04 100% relevant
Yglesias’s examples: plumbers (more conservative, practical) versus overwhelmingly left‑leaning academics and scientists; the heat‑pump/HVAC skepticism example showing how shared expert values intersect with policy uptake.
← Back to All Ideas