Judicial originalism as actually practiced emphasizes role‑constraints: judges must weigh practical consequences, build majorities, and respect stare decisis even while invoking original meaning. The phrase captures a pragmatic subtype of originalism that treats scholarly regulative ideals as guides rather than binding scripts for every case.
— This framing reframes debates over the Supreme Court from abstract fidelity to constitutional text to a practical negotiation among institutional duties, affecting public expectations about rulings and reform proposals.
John O. McGinnis & Mike Rappaport
2026.11.16
100% relevant
Justice Samuel Alito’s book So Ordered and his repeated self‑labeling as a “working judicial originalist,” plus anecdotes about draft opinions being ‘brutalized’ to secure a majority, illustrate the idea.
← Back to all ideas