Knowledge Beats Single Reasoning Tests

Updated: 2025.09.29 23D ago 1 sources
The author argues that in populations with similar access to education and information, a general-knowledge test can outpredict a one-off reasoning test for underlying problem-solving ability. Knowledge acts like a long-term average of cognitive performance, while a single reasoning measure is a noisy snapshot. — This reframes how schools and employers should design assessments and interpret scores, pushing toward batteries and context-appropriate proxies rather than standalone reasoning tests.

Sources

Is g Real or Just Statistics? A Monologue with a Testable Prediction
Davide Piffer 2025.09.29 100% relevant
Claim that 'g or general knowledge can in certain contexts proxy underlying capacity better than a single direct reasoning test' contingent on 'epistemic opportunity parity.'
← Back to All Ideas