A recent cohort study of political‑science PhD job outcomes (Desposato) finds that being female or an underrepresented minority materially increased the odds of landing a tenure‑track assistant professorship in 2023, even after controlling for program rank, publications, and field. Simple demographic status appears to have been a stronger predictor of hiring success than many traditional merit signals except an individually authored top‑journal article.
— If replicated more widely, this reverses a central assumption about academic bias and will reshape public debates on affirmative action, meritocracy, and the legitimacy of university hiring policies.
Steve Stewart-Williams
2026.09.17
100% relevant
Scott Desposato’s paper tracking 400+ 2023 political‑science PhD job‑seekers and John Holbein’s illustrative probability calculations showing a white man with identical credentials fared worse than women and minority candidates.
← Back to all ideas